ewilen (ewilen) wrote,

Is roleplaying a fundamental (and noteworthy) human activity?

Sorry, this is just a note, that may be expanded some time in the future.

1. Some excellent discussion between Cole and Géza Echs buried here: http://www.therpgsite.com/showthread.php?t=20020 They talk about whether the action of an RPG session can be compared to a camping trip, or a narrative about a camping trip.

2. Excellent post by Drolyt, which explains something I touched on in the above thread, only much more clearly than I did: http://www.tgdmb.com/viewtopic.php?p=335116 He talks about cops & robbers vs. chess vs. D&D.

3. It all goes back to ritual as discussed by Chris Lehrich.

See also Magic Circle.

The hard issues here are, first, the alleged distinction between "imaginary events" and "narrative." See also: speech-act. Arguably ritual/roleplay is an area where speech acts are vastly expanded, and they act on complex constellations of concepts.

Second: the alleged identification of player with character.

  • Interpreting failure and dice rolls in-game

    Here's one idea I first came across in discussions about Theatrix, which was also highlighted by some old Forgie-story-gamer discussion. It dovetails…

  • Excellent post on dissociated mechanics

    A recent thread on rpg.net has some excellent posts by 105349 and StrollofTurtle, but cmdicely offers a profound insight in post #615 Most of what…

  • More on immersion confusion

    Two articles have recently come to my attention: The Play of Simulation (excerpt from Salen and Zimmerman, Rules of Play: Game Design…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded